In The Age of Robotic-Assisted Surgery, Who Takes the Fall?
By: Georgina Michelle
Few experiences are as nerve-wracking as being wheeled into surgery, and for a growing number of patients, that anxiety now includes trusting their surgeon to perform the operation with the assistance of robotic technology. If a procedure goes wrong due to a defect in the surgical robot, the question arises of who to blame: the surgeon or the manufacturers of the defective robot? In recent years, medical malpractice claims involving robotic-assisted surgeries have shot up dramatically.[1] The expansion of robotic technology in surgery has been particularly revolutionary due to its minimally invasive operative approach.[2] However, as with any technology, the risk of a defective product or an erroneous performance remains a real worry.
In one case, a patient underwent surgery for the treatment of adenocarcinoma in his prostate, during which a surgical robot, known as the da Vinci Surgical System, was used to perform part of the surgery.[3] However, in the middle of the surgery, the robot displayed error messages repeatedly, despite the surgical team attempting to reboot the robot’s system several times.[4] As a result, the robot was inoperable, and the surgical team had to resort to finishing the surgery using laparoscopic equipment.[5] A week after the surgery took place, the patient had to be readmitted to the hospital due to gross hematuria, while also suffering from complications such as severe abdominal pain and erectile dysfunction (ED).[6] The court ultimately held that the patient failed to produce an expert report to back the claims for strict product liability and breach of warranty, along with failure to produce evidence of causation between the use of the da Vinci robot during his surgery and his subsequent diagnosis with ED.[7]
In Reece v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc., a patient received surgery with the assistance of the same da Vinci Surgical System mentioned in the previous case.[8] In this case, the patient received surgery to treat his prostate cancer diagnosis.[9] However, during the procedure, the patient sustained injuries to his internal organs, such as his intestines and small bowels, as a result of the use of the da Vinci robot.[10] Consequently, the patient endured eight follow-up procedures and a forty-four-day extended stay in the hospital.[11] The patient’s wife brought suit against the manufacturer of the robot for product liability and negligence, among other claims, which survived a motion to dismiss by the defendant.[12]
In these cases, patients alleged subsequent harm because of the use of robotic technology during their respective surgeries. In both cases, the patients chose to bring suit against the manufacturers of the robotic technology, rather than the surgeon. However, with human oversight still a necessary factor in conducting such procedures, the question remains whether responsibility should be assigned to the physicians overseeing the surgery. Should physicians be assigned partial or complete responsibility? Additionally, as with any emerging technology, a spectrum of legal uncertainties exists regarding the legal framework under which it can be categorized. For example, would the existing tort framework be sufficient to address patient injuries resulting from robotic-assisted surgery, and if so, to whom should liability primarily be assigned? At the same time, the threat of recurring, expensive litigation could potentially discourage manufacturers from creating and innovating in the surgical robot industry, a cost that patients themselves would ultimately have to bear.
Perhaps the answer lies somewhere in the idea that protecting innovation and efficiency and protecting patients are not necessarily diametrically opposed goals. However, achieving both will likely require establishing a clear standard regarding the responsibilities of the physician using the surgical robots, standardizing governance of training and accreditation, and potentially creating a system of oversight for the creation and development of surgical robot technology.
[1] Emma De Ravin et al., Medical Malpractice in Robotic Surgery: A Westlaw Database Analysis, 17 J. Robotic Surgery 191 (2022).
[2] Id.
[3] Mracek v. Bryn Mawr Hosp., 610 F. Supp. 2d 401, 402 (E.D. Pa. 2009).
[4] Id. at 403.
[5] Id.
[6] Id.
[7] Id. at 406.
[8] Reece v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc., 63 F. Supp. 3d 1337, 1338 (N.D. Ala. 2014).
[9] Id. at 1339.
[10] Id.
[11] Id.
[12] Id. at 1337.